New Streetcar Route
(Photo: Adam J. Benjamin)
City leaders have settled on a preferred route for a proposed streetcar system through downtown and Over-the-Rhine. To ensure the system generates the most redevelopment spin-off on surrounding blocks, the chosen route is longer than initially discussed and covers a larger area.
Although three different routes — each about four miles long — originally were mulled, city planners have chosen a slightly altered version that is 4.6 miles in length. Cincinnati City Architect Michael Moore said HDR Engineering Inc. complete an economic feasibility study of the route in mid-May.
The preferred route has three segments. To view the route, click here.
Under the alignment, the streetcars would begin their journey on Elm Street and travel northward to McMicken Avenue before turning and traveling south on Race Street. It continues on Race until it hits Central Parkway, where it turns east and travels to Walnut Street.
At that point, the system goes south down Walnut to the future Freedom Way along the riverfront, where it turns north again and travels up Main Street until it reaches 12th Street. At 12th, it turns west and travels until it reaches the origin point on Elm.
The route was selected for purposes of doing the feasibility study and could be changed later in the project if it’s ever built.
“A preferred alignment that we actually build will involve a whole lot more public input,” Moore said. “This just gives us something to work with, a starting point.”
The route was picked, in part, because of its potential to spark redevelopment. Since Portland, Ore., opened the nation’s first modern streetcar system in 2001, land development there has rapidly accelerated, mostly through the construction of apartments and condominiums.
Overall, $2.28 billion in new development has occurred within a two-block radius of Portland’s streetcar system since it opened. The investment includes more than 7,200 new housing units and 4.6 million square feet of new business space. About 55 percent of all new development in Portland’s downtown during the past decade has occurred within one block of the system.
Here city planners and consultants examined a three-block radius around the route, Moore said.
“Within that radius, we grab just about everything in Over-the-Rhine by doing that and, looking east, we pick up some key ridership from the office blocks,” he said.
The feasibility study will cost about $200,000 and is being done with a combination of city and private funds. After the study is completed, Cincinnati City Council will decide whether to move ahead with the project. If approval is granted, the system likely would cost about $100 million and could be completed by 2011.
— Kevin Osborne

April 23, 2007 at 7:03 pm
Wondering what a Modern Streetcar is?
Watch this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xL7QEQuRqq0
April 23, 2007 at 7:05 pm
$20 million per mile. This is nothing but the latest pie-in-the-sky idea from our dysfunctional council
April 23, 2007 at 8:47 pm
It should go up the hill to UC and Pill Hill & Ludlow to really work.
And to conductor – look around – its worked magnifcently in other places – but of course we wouldn’t want to to look that far away would we?
April 23, 2007 at 9:24 pm
The streetcar system will be a tremendous boost for the city. The above article gives the essential facts: “$2.28 billion in new development has occurred within a two-block radius of Portland’s streetcar system since it opened.”
April 24, 2007 at 12:24 am
What a great thing for Cincinnati. After years of being a “wait and see” city, we’re joining in where many other cities have already taken the lead. This streetcar will open up so many places to people with limited mobility from OTR to the river and back!!
Just think… our residents will be able to go home, hop the trolley and go to the pharmacy, the bank, the club, the restaurant and the grocery… ALL WITHOUT NEEDING TO DRIVE!
How remarkable our city is moving forward!
This makes me wonder out loud how much more desirable City Living will become.
April 24, 2007 at 10:53 am
Maybe the best thing about this route is the attention it will bring to the stupendous buildings in the brewery district north of Findlay Market. The second best thing will be the realization that Elm Street needs only cleaning and buffing to look like a Vincent Minelli dream of a perfect streetcar street.
April 24, 2007 at 11:27 am
Well–correlation isn’t causation, so I’m not sure that anyone can assert that the streetcar actually caused the $2.28 billion in new development. How much would have happened without the streetcar? It’s worth asking.
Anyone here actually ridden the Portland Streetcar? I have, from 23rd Street toward downtown. Somewhere in the Pearl, I got off and started walking, because it seemed so slow. I figured I might get a little exercise on a nice day and arrive at roughly the same time.
Think I’m against the streetcar? Not at all. I’d simply be thankful if the idea wasn’t oversold. My recollection of the Pearl district is that it was, unlike OTR, mostly warehouse-loft sort of buildings, and virgin territory for establishing residences. Taking that parallel, the most promising part of OTR for Pearl-style redevelopment would be the Brewery District. Nice to see that the streetcar route goes right there.
On a more general level, building the streetcar would connect some of the great things that make urban living different from neighborhood or suburban life. At some point of adoption, that would include the streetcar itself. And the cost of $20 million/mile…it’s comparable to the per-mile cost of the widening of I-275 from Winton to US 42. (http://www.dot.state.oh.us/trac/2008-2013/2008-2013MajorNew12-20-06.pdf).
April 24, 2007 at 2:36 pm
Remember that number: $100 million. I’ll bet the final cost will be in the $250-300 million range. For reference, the Fort Washington Way redesign was supposed to cost $96 million. Final cost: $304 million.
April 24, 2007 at 3:13 pm
Stephan (Conductor), since we’re talking about costs per mile, let’s not limit it to the streetcar. How about:
* Fort Washington Way: $400 million per mile
* New Brent Spence Bridge: probably $1 billion per mile
* New north/south runway at CVG: $50 million per mile
* Government Square: $140 million per mile
The point is, all this stuff is expernsive. When fuel prices skyrocket over the next few years, we’ll be able to judge whether all the investments that depend on cheap oil pass muster.
My guess is, some won’t, but the streetcar will.
April 25, 2007 at 11:52 am
While I support public transportation, I know two urban planners who live in work in Portland who maintain the streetcar/development link is unproven.
April 25, 2007 at 5:56 pm
This looks fantastic and Cincinnati really needs to take the risk. I actually think heading up the hills should wait a little bit. First, the system should connect to Union Terminal. That would allow for family-type visitors to get over there easily and would set the stage for the expansion of useful inter-city rail when carbon taxes make car rides back and forth across the Midwest less enticing. Finally, it would provide a real boost to the City West development and consolidate its inconclusion in the Greater Downtown Region.
I rode Philly’s streetcar a lot this winter, while it isn’t the fastest on earth and yes sometimes it is nicer to walk, it makes the whole city more accessible. The buses there are interminably slow going in the center city. Fortunately, Philly included the trolleys in the subway system in the Center City area, which might not be a bad idea for using our own tunnels for something similar.
April 26, 2007 at 2:26 am
[...] SPEAKER & TOPIC: As a former senior communications specialist and strategist for Transport for London (London’s public transportation body), Antoine Clarke has been deeply involved in the public consultation for initiatives such as London’s traffic congestion charge and the Thames Gateway Bridge. Drawing on his experience and knowledge of global public transportation, and in light of Cincinnati’s developing plans for a municipal streetcar and/or light rail system, Antoine will be talking about how various world cities have approached similar endeavors. What works? What doesn’t? What should taxpayers demand of public transportation? Antoine will tell us, and tailor his remarks with regard for the plans currently underway in Cincinnati. [...]